I love America. Love it to death. However, I disagree greatly with it's dogmas and faith. It's based upon freedom. Freedom of Press. Freedom of Speech. Freedom of Religion.
As an American, these all sound good, right? Hey man, do whatever, as long as it doesn't harm others! You can do ANYTHING, but just keep within these wide boundaries. That's fine, right?
For the Catholic, wrong...
Just a cursory knowledge of Catholic principles of freedom (as eloquently espoused in Mirari Vos which everybody should read!) would tell you that these are wrong. Having any laws other than Catholic ones puts the state at odds with the Church. It puts the state over the Church, when it should be the other way around. The best and most logical form of government is the Church above the state (in matters of faith and morals). As Matthew 12:30 states, "He that is not with me, is against me".
As the early Christians under Roman rule obeyed it's laws while being tortured and killed, so too must Americans, as long as it does not conflict with the Catholic Religion.
As St. Augustine wrote about the early Christians living under the pagan Romans, they were "Christian soldiers, (that) served an infidel emperor. When the issue of Christ was raised, they acknowledged no one but the One who is in heaven. They distinguished the eternal Lord from the temporal lord, but were also subject to the temporal lord for the sake of the eternal Lord." This teaches us to do our best to serve our government with all it's governors, judges and senators with the utmost obedience, but make our Jesus Christ, our Lord and God number one in our lives. If the two conflict, God should (and eventually will) be the victor. As Thomas More said moments before his death in 1535, "I die the king's faithful servant, but God's first." So as much as I dislike Obama, if he says "Jump", I'll ask "How high?", but as long as it doesn't conflict with Catholicism. As Romans states, "There is no authority except from God; what authority there is has been appointed by God. Therefore he who resists authority resists the ordinances of God; and those who resist bring on themselves condemnation."
So once we have this down, what about the freedoms? The Catholic opinion is confusing at first to the modern mind, but makes sense. If certain press and speech are harmful to the mind and spirit, what business does it have in society? Let me ask further, why are some weapons or poisons illegal to have in society? It's because they cause great unnecessary harm to people's bodies. Similarly, many public speakers, movies and magazines cause great harm to people's spiritual and moral welfare. Why should they be legal? As for freedom of religion, we must define freedom. In this case, it means to ability and acceptance of worshiping what you want, where you want. The true Catholic has always been against this in society. His position is that people may believe what they want and worship how they please, but in private. For example, they may not get public funding nor have a procession in the streets. This is to keep the people from spiritual sickness of anti-Catholicism.
This is how it was back in the Middle Ages. I wish it was this healthy today, but I'm afraid society must get worse before it will get better. Catholics today are under indirect malevolence, whether it be from the media's portrayal of things, government taxes for abortion, or "hate" speech. But until it does get better, remember to pray the Rosary, go to mass and make use of those sacramentals!

As an American, these all sound good, right? Hey man, do whatever, as long as it doesn't harm others! You can do ANYTHING, but just keep within these wide boundaries. That's fine, right?
For the Catholic, wrong...
Just a cursory knowledge of Catholic principles of freedom (as eloquently espoused in Mirari Vos which everybody should read!) would tell you that these are wrong. Having any laws other than Catholic ones puts the state at odds with the Church. It puts the state over the Church, when it should be the other way around. The best and most logical form of government is the Church above the state (in matters of faith and morals). As Matthew 12:30 states, "He that is not with me, is against me".
As the early Christians under Roman rule obeyed it's laws while being tortured and killed, so too must Americans, as long as it does not conflict with the Catholic Religion.
As St. Augustine wrote about the early Christians living under the pagan Romans, they were "Christian soldiers, (that) served an infidel emperor. When the issue of Christ was raised, they acknowledged no one but the One who is in heaven. They distinguished the eternal Lord from the temporal lord, but were also subject to the temporal lord for the sake of the eternal Lord." This teaches us to do our best to serve our government with all it's governors, judges and senators with the utmost obedience, but make our Jesus Christ, our Lord and God number one in our lives. If the two conflict, God should (and eventually will) be the victor. As Thomas More said moments before his death in 1535, "I die the king's faithful servant, but God's first." So as much as I dislike Obama, if he says "Jump", I'll ask "How high?", but as long as it doesn't conflict with Catholicism. As Romans states, "There is no authority except from God; what authority there is has been appointed by God. Therefore he who resists authority resists the ordinances of God; and those who resist bring on themselves condemnation."
So once we have this down, what about the freedoms? The Catholic opinion is confusing at first to the modern mind, but makes sense. If certain press and speech are harmful to the mind and spirit, what business does it have in society? Let me ask further, why are some weapons or poisons illegal to have in society? It's because they cause great unnecessary harm to people's bodies. Similarly, many public speakers, movies and magazines cause great harm to people's spiritual and moral welfare. Why should they be legal? As for freedom of religion, we must define freedom. In this case, it means to ability and acceptance of worshiping what you want, where you want. The true Catholic has always been against this in society. His position is that people may believe what they want and worship how they please, but in private. For example, they may not get public funding nor have a procession in the streets. This is to keep the people from spiritual sickness of anti-Catholicism.
This is how it was back in the Middle Ages. I wish it was this healthy today, but I'm afraid society must get worse before it will get better. Catholics today are under indirect malevolence, whether it be from the media's portrayal of things, government taxes for abortion, or "hate" speech. But until it does get better, remember to pray the Rosary, go to mass and make use of those sacramentals!


